Cleveland Golf Cleveland HB Soft 2 Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared

How each alternative compares

Cleveland HB Soft 2 Putter 34" Center Shafted

This Cleveland HB Soft 2 #11 Putter keeps the 34-inch shaft length and silver finish of the original but shifts to a center-shafted design. The plumber's neck hosel is replaced by a central shaft, which increases stability for straight stroke players. It retains the Speed Optimized Face Technology for consistent ball speed across the striking area. The oversized grip adds control. You lose the specific toe hang and alignment cues of the plumber's neck, gaining a more stable feel. Pick this if you want the same face technology but prefer a center-shafted mallet look for improved stability during your putting stroke.

Odyssey Square 2 Square 34" Double Wide

The Odyssey AI-One Square 2 Square offers a 34-inch length like the original but features a black color and center-shafted mallet head. It uses AI-optimized design for face control, differing from the original's dynamic groove milling. The double-wide mallet shape provides significant stability compared to the original's blade-style plumber's neck. You gain enhanced forgiveness on off-center hits and a forward press setup feel. You give up the specific silver aesthetic and the traditional plumber's neck geometry. This option suits players who prioritize face control and a stable mallet profile over the original's straight-stroke specific hosel design.

Cobra Classic Mallet Putter 34"

This Cobra Classic Mallet Putter maintains the 34-inch shaft length and silver color but switches to a traditional mallet head shape. It features a single-sightline alignment system, contrasting with the original's plumber's neck alignment cues. The steel shaft offers traditional stability, similar to the original's feel but with a mallet profile. You gain a simpler visual alignment aid and a mallet-style head. You lose the Speed Optimized Face Technology and the specific plumber's neck geometry. This pick is ideal for players who value traditional steel shaft stability and simple alignment over the original's advanced face milling and hosel-specific stroke matching.

Cleveland Retreve HB Soft 2 35" Putter

The Cleveland HB Soft 2 Retreve Putter increases the shaft length to 35 inches, offering a longer option compared to the original's 34-inch shaft. It retains the silver color and Speed Optimized Face Technology for consistent distance. The unique retrieval feature adds convenience not present in the original model. You gain a longer shaft for players who prefer a 35-inch length and an oversized grip for control. You maintain the same face technology and right-hand orientation. This alternative is best for right-handed golfers who need a slightly longer shaft while keeping the consistent speed and familiar Cleveland face milling technology.

TaylorMade Spider RED #3 34" Mallet

The TaylorMade Spider RED #3 Putter features a 34-inch length and red color, differing from the original's silver finish. It uses a multi-material mallet construction for high stability, contrasting with the original's blade-style plumber's neck. The design enhances roll characteristics, offering a different feel than the original's speed-optimized face. You gain a high-MOI mallet head for forgiveness and a distinct red aesthetic. You lose the specific plumber's neck geometry and the dynamic groove milling pattern. This option suits right-handed golfers seeking high stability and a mallet profile over the original's straight-stroke specific hosel and blade design.

TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter #3 34"

The TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter #3 offers a 34-inch length and black color, differing from the original's silver plumber's neck blade. It features a high-MOI mallet head for stability, contrasting with the original's specific hosel design. The distinct black finish provides visual alignment cues, while the heavier head profile offers a stable feel. You gain a mallet-style forgiveness and a black aesthetic. You lose the Speed Optimized Face Technology and the plumber's neck geometry. This pick is ideal for right-handed golfers who prioritize a stable black mallet and visual alignment over the original's specific stroke-matching hosel and face milling technology.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 10.5 34"

Best for: right-handers with straight putting strokes

Hand Orientation

Right Hand

Shaft Length

34 inches

Neck Type

Plumber's Neck

Face Technology

Speed Optimized Face Technology

Color

Silver

Dimensions

43 × 5 × 6 inches

View on Amazon: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Model 10.5 34" Affiliate link

This Cleveland HB Soft 2 putter features a 34-inch shaft and a plumber's neck hosel, designed for straight or slight arc strokes. The silver mallet head uses Speed Optimized Face Technology to normalize ball speed across an enlarged striking area. It is a right-hand model weighing 0.71 ounces. The design syncs the hosel, toe hang, and alignment system for consistent feel.

Pros

• Speed Optimized Face Technology normalizes ball speed for consistent distance
• Plumber's neck hosel suits straight or slight arc strokes
• 34-inch shaft length provides standard reach
• Right-hand configuration with silver finish

Cons

• Only available in right-hand orientation
• Limited to plumber's neck style without center-shaft options
• No weight customization beyond the included 20g butt-end weight for longer shafts

Good fit if

• You prefer a plumber's neck hosel for a straight putting stroke
• You want a 34-inch shaft length for comfortable posture
• You play right-handed and need a silver finish

Skip if

• You require a left-hand configuration
• You need a center-shaft mallet design
• You prefer a black color option

Verdict: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Putter 34" Plumber's Neck delivers consistent speed through its face milling and suits right-handers with straight strokes. It fits players who value a 34-inch shaft and plumber's neck geometry over other hosel styles.

2 Also great

Cleveland HB Soft 2 Putter 34" Center Shafted

Best for: straight stroke players seeking stability

Hand Orientation

Right Hand

Shaft Length

34"

Face Technology

Speed Optimized Face Technology

Grip Type

Oversized Grip

Color

Silver

Dimensions

43 × 5 × 6 inches

View on Amazon: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Putter 34" Center Shafted Affiliate link

This right-handed mallet features a 34-inch shaft and an oversized grip. It uses Speed Optimized Face Technology to normalize ball speed across a larger striking area. The center-shafted design with an oversized grip suits straight or slight arc strokes. It offers consistent swing feel and predictable distance performance for players seeking stability.

Pros

• Speed Optimized Face Technology normalizes ball speed
• Oversized grip for enhanced stability
• Center shafted design for straight strokes
• 34-inch shaft length

Cons

• Limited to right-hand orientation only
• Oversized grip may feel bulky for some
• No adjustable weight ports mentioned in data

Good fit if

• You prefer a straight putting stroke
• You want a larger striking area
• You need a 34-inch shaft

Skip if

• You are a left-handed golfer
• You prefer a slant neck design
• You want a single bend shaft

Verdict: Cleveland HB Soft 2 #11 Putter, 34 inch suits players with straight strokes who value consistent distance. The oversized grip and face technology provide stability for reliable putting performance.

3 Also great

Odyssey Square 2 Square 34" Double Wide

Best for: players seeking a stable center-shafted mallet

Hand Orientation

Right Hand

Shaft Length

34"

Face Technology

Ai-ONE Insert

Grip Type

Oversized Grip

Color

Black

Dimensions

43 × 5 × 6 inches

View on Amazon: Odyssey Square 2 Square 34" Double Wide Affiliate link

The Odyssey Square to Square Putter features a 34-inch length and a 5-inch wide double-wide mallet head. It uses an AI-designed insert with an aluminum backer and White Hot urethane to promote consistent ball speed. The modern center shafted design includes a built-in forward press to help square the face. An oversized grip and navy blue PVD finish complete the premium build.

Pros

• AI-One insert with aluminum backer for consistent ball speed
• Center shafted design with built-in forward press
• 5-inch wide double-wide mallet head
• Oversized grip for secure control

Cons

• Only available in right-hand orientation
• Heavier double-wide head may not suit arc stroke players
• Single shaft style option limits customization

Good fit if

• You prefer a center-shafted mallet design
• You want a wider head for stability
• You like a forward press setup

Skip if

• You need a left-handed model
• You prefer a single-bend shaft
• You want a smaller blade head

Verdict: Odyssey AI-One Square 2 Square Putter is a stable, AI-optimized choice for players who prefer a center-shafted mallet. It suits those who value face control and a forward press setup over lightweight blade designs.

4 Also great

Cobra Classic Mallet Putter 34"

Best for: Traditional mallet putter seekers

Shaft Length

34

Shaft Material

Steel

Alignment System

Single Sightline

Color

Silver

Weight

1.38 pounds

View on Amazon: Cobra Classic Mallet Putter 34" Affiliate link

The Cobra Classic Mallet Putter offers a 34-inch steel shaft for consistent feel and control. Its CNC-machined face delivers a soft impact sound, while the single sightline alignment aids setup. Weighing 1.38 pounds, this silver mallet putter suits players seeking a traditional, stable stroke with precise face machining.

Pros

• CNC-machined face for precision and soft feel
• Single sightline alignment for confident setup
• Traditional steel shaft for stability
• Mallet head design for balance

Cons

• Only one shaft length available in data
• No adjustable weighting system mentioned
• Single alignment option limits customization

Good fit if

• You prefer a traditional steel shaft feel
• You want a clean single sightline for alignment
• You like a stable mallet head design

Skip if

• You need multiple shaft length options
• You prefer blade-style putters over mallets
• You want complex multi-sightline alignment systems

Verdict: Cobra Classic Mallet Putter, 34" fits players who value traditional steel shaft stability and simple single-sightline alignment for a consistent putting stroke.

5 Best budget

Cleveland Retreve HB Soft 2 35" Putter

Best for: Right-handed players needing a 35-inch shaft

Hand Orientation

Right Hand

Shaft Length

35 inches

Neck Type

Single Bend

Face Technology

Speed Optimized Face Technology

Grip Type

Oversized Grip

Age Range

Ages 3-5

View on Amazon: Cleveland Retreve HB Soft 2 35" Putter Affiliate link

This Cleveland HB Soft 2 Retreve putter features a 35-inch shaft and single bend neck for right-handed players. Its oversized grip and Speed Optimized Face Technology normalize ball speed across an enlarged striking area. The unique Retreve head shape allows you to pick the ball out of the hole easily. It includes a 20g weight in the butt end for consistent feel. This model suits those seeking a straight or slight arc stroke design.

Pros

• Speed Optimized Face Technology normalizes ball speed
• Retreve head shape picks ball out of hole
• Oversized grip for enhanced control
• Single bend neck for straight stroke alignment
• 20g butt weight for consistent swing feel

Cons

• 35-inch length exceeds standard 34-inch preference
• Single bend neck limits toe hang options
• Oversized grip may feel bulky for small hands

Good fit if

• You prefer a 35-inch shaft length
• You want an oversized grip for stability
• You need a head that picks the ball out

Skip if

• You require a 34-inch shaft length
• You prefer a center-shafted mallet design
• You need a left-hand configuration

Verdict: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Retreve 35" Putter offers a unique retrieval feature and speed-optimized face for consistent distance. It is best for right-handed golfers who prefer a longer 35-inch shaft and an oversized grip.

6 Best red

TaylorMade Spider RED #3 34" Mallet

Best for: right-handed golfers seeking high stability

Shaft Length

34"

Head Style

Mallet

Face Technology

Pure Roll Insert

MOI Characteristics

High MOI

Hand Orientation

Right

Color

Red

View on Amazon: TaylorMade Spider RED #3 34" Mallet Affiliate link

This TaylorMade Spider RED putter features a high-MOI mallet head with a stainless steel frame and aluminum core. The 34-inch shaft suits standard setups. A Pure Roll insert promotes forward roll for better distance control. Vibration-damping foam improves sound and feel. It is designed for golfers seeking stability and consistent face alignment through multi-material construction.

Pros

• High MOI from stainless steel frame and aluminum core
• Pure Roll insert increases topspin and forward roll
• Vibration-damping PU foam enhances sound and feel
• Available in right and left hand orientations

Cons

• Mallet head shape may not suit stroke purists
• Fixed 34-inch length not adjustable
• No alignment aid details provided in specs

Good fit if

• You want a high-MOI mallet for stability
• You prefer a 34-inch shaft length
• You are a right-handed golfer

Skip if

• You need a left-handed option for this specific red model
• You prefer a blade-style putter
• You require an adjustable shaft length

Verdict: TaylorMade Spider RED Mallet Putter offers high stability through its multi-material construction. It fits right-handed players seeking a 34-inch mallet with enhanced roll characteristics.

7 Best premium

TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter #3 34"

Best for: Right-handed golfers seeking a stable black mallet

Hand Orientation

Right Hand

Shaft Length

34 Inches

Head Style

Spider Tour #3

Alignment System

patented alignment system

MOI Characteristics

high-MOI

Color

Black

View on Amazon: TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter #3 34" Affiliate link

The TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter is a high-MOI mallet designed for stability and forgiveness. It features a 34-inch shaft and a patented alignment system to help you visualize your putting line. The head measures 6 inches wide and 6 inches high, offering a substantial profile. The durable PVD coating provides a black finish with copper accents. This right-hand model suits golfers seeking consistency and a distinct visual aesthetic on the green.

Pros

• High-MOI head design for stability and forgiveness
• Patented alignment system for visual clarity
• Durable PVD coating with copper accents
• TSS weights for balanced performance

Cons

• Right-hand orientation only
• Heavier build at 1.2 pounds
• Limited to single shaft style in this variant

Good fit if

• You prefer a high-MOI mallet for stability
• You want a black finish with copper accents
• You need a 34-inch shaft length

Skip if

• You play left-handed
• You prefer a lighter putter under 1.2 pounds
• You need multiple shaft style options in one listing

Verdict: TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter offers high-MOI stability and a distinct black finish for right-handed golfers who prioritize visual alignment cues and a heavier, stable head profile.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions

See also

• cleveland golf cleveland hb soft 2 alternatives
• realtruck extang trifecta 2 0 soft alternatives