Odyssey Square to Square Putter Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
The Odyssey Square to Square Putter offers a center-shafted Jailbird design with an oversized grip and a 35-inch length. This model uses an Ai-ONE insert to promote consistent ball speed and a built-in forward press to reduce face opening. If you are looking for odyssey square to square putter alternatives, you might want a different brand or spec profile. Some golfers prefer a heavier mallet for more stability, while others seek a traditional blade feel or a left-handed configuration. The original weighs 1.2 pounds, which is lighter than many mallet options in this list.
We selected these 6 picks because their specifications overlap with the original. You will find options with similar 35-inch lengths but different head shapes and weights. For example, the TaylorMade Spider X Black weighs 3.1 pounds, offering a much heavier, balanced feel. Other choices include the TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1, which provides a classic blade aesthetic with a Pure Roll insert. The Cleveland HB Soft 2 models offer center-shafted stability with oversized grips, similar to the original. These alternatives cover a range of styles, from mallets to blades, ensuring you find a putter that matches your specific stroke and preference.
Our top pick: Odyssey Square to Square Jailbird 35" Putter.
Comparing 6 Similar Putter Options
TaylorMade Spider X Black 35" Putter
The TaylorMade Spider X Black offers a mallet design rather than the Jailbird shape. It features a 5-inch width and 5-inch height for high stability. At 3.1 pounds, it is significantly heavier than the 1.2-pound Odyssey. This weight aids in smoothing out strokes. The 48-inch length is an option, though the 35-inch version matches the original. You gain alignment clarity and balance. You lose the specific forward-press geometry of the Square to Square. This pick suits players who prioritize maximum stability and a heavier feel over a traditional center-shafted blade look.
Odyssey Microhinge Seven DB Putter
The Odyssey Microhinge Seven DB retains the brand but switches to a classic blade shape. It uses a Microhinge insert for immediate ball roll instead of the Ai-ONE insert. The model is designed for players who trust Versa Alignment. Like the original, it comes in a 35-inch length for right-handed users. You get a traditional aesthetic and roll-focused performance. You give up the oversized grip and the center-shafted Jailbird stability. This alternative is for golfers who prefer a blade profile and immediate forward roll over the modern, stable design of the Square to Square.
TaylorMade TP Black Putter Soto #1 35"
The TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 is a traditional blade with a 6-inch width. It weighs only 6.07 ounces, making it much lighter than the 1.2-pound Odyssey. The 36-inch length is slightly longer than the 35-inch original. It features a Pure Roll insert for roll optimization. You get a classic aesthetic and precise face technology. You lose the oversized grip and the forward-press center-shafted design. This pick is for players who prioritize a lightweight, traditional feel and specific roll characteristics over the stability and modern geometry of the Square to Square Jailbird.
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Putter
The Cleveland HB Soft 2 is a center-shafted mallet similar to the original. It features a 5-inch width and 6-inch height. The 43-inch length is an option, differing from the 35-inch original. It uses a UST Mamiya shaft and an oversized grip like the Odyssey. You gain a stable, straight-stroke solution with consistent ball speed. You lose the Ai-ONE insert and the specific Jailbird head shape. This alternative suits right-handed players who prioritize face stability and a specialized shaft feel over the specific forward-press geometry and lighter weight of the Square to Square.
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Putter
The Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Retreve is the left-handed version of the previous model. It shares the same 5-inch width and 6-inch height. The 43-inch length option differs from the 35-inch original. It includes an oversized grip and specialized shaft for stability. You gain a stable option for left-handed golfers with straight strokes. You lose the Ai-ONE insert and the Jailbird design. This pick is for left-handed players who value consistent ball speed and face stability over the specific forward-press geometry and lighter weight of the right-handed Square to Square.
Odyssey DFX Putter V Line Fang 35"
The Odyssey DFX V-Line Fang is a mallet putter with a 5-inch width and 6-inch height. It comes in a 42-inch length, differing from the 35-inch original. It features a larger grip and a charcoal finish. You gain a stable mallet head with a classic shape. You lose the Ai-ONE insert and the forward-press center-shafted design. This alternative suits right-handed golfers who prefer a mallet head and a larger grip over the specific Jailbird profile. It offers a modern aesthetic with stable performance, differing significantly in length and head shape from the Square to Square.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
Odyssey Square to Square Jailbird 35" Putter
Best for: Right-handed golfers wanting a center-shafted Jailbird design
- Hand Orientation
- Right Hand
- Shaft Length
- 35"
- Face Technology
- Ai-ONE Insert
- Grip Type
- Oversized Grip
- Age Range
- Ages 3-5
- Color
- Black
View on Amazon: Odyssey Square to Square Jailbird 35" Putter Affiliate link
This center-shafted putter features a Jailbird head with an Ai-ONE insert. The insert uses an aluminum backer with co-molded White Hot urethane to promote consistent ball speed. A built-in forward press aligns the shaft above the center of gravity. It includes an oversized grip for control. The 35-inch length and 1.2-pound weight offer a balanced feel for right-handed players.
Pros
- Ai-ONE insert with aluminum backer for consistent ball speed
- Center-shafted design with built-in forward press
- Oversized grip for a secure feel
- Co-molded White Hot urethane layer
Cons
- Only available in right-hand orientation
- Heavier 1.2-pound head weight
- Single center-shaft style only
Good fit if
- You prefer a center-shafted putter design
- You want an oversized grip for control
- You play with a right-handed stance
Skip if
- You need a left-handed option
- You prefer a single-bend shaft
- You want a lighter head weight
Verdict: Odyssey Square to Square Jailbird Putter suits players who want a center-shafted design with an oversized grip. It is a solid choice for right-handed golfers seeking consistent ball speed.
TaylorMade Spider X Black 35" Putter
Best for: Right-handed golfers seeking stability
- Hand Orientation
- Right Hand
- Shaft Length
- 35"
- Head Style
- Spider
- Alignment System
- Patented alignment system
- Age Range
- Ages 3-5
- Color
- Black
View on Amazon: TaylorMade Spider X Black 35" Putter Affiliate link
The TaylorMade Spider X Black is a 35-inch right-handed putter designed for stability. It features a patented alignment system to help you visualize your line. TSS weights provide balanced weighting across various lengths. The durable PVD coating offers a high-quality finish with copper accents. This model suits golfers seeking championship-level stability and clear visual guidance on the green.
Pros
- Patented alignment system for visual clarity
- TSS weights for balanced performance
- Durable PVD coating with copper accents
- Championship-winning stability design
Cons
- Heavier build at 3.1 pounds
- Limited to right-hand orientation in this listing
- No remote or app connectivity
Good fit if
- You want a mallet-style putter for stability
- You prefer a black finish with copper details
- You need a 35-inch shaft length
Skip if
- You play left-handed
- You prefer a lighter putter under 3 pounds
- You need a center-shafted design
Verdict: TaylorMade Spider X Black 35" Putter is a stable, right-handed mallet putter for golfers who value clear alignment and a heavier, balanced feel.
Odyssey Microhinge Seven DB Putter
Best for: Right-handed players wanting immediate roll
- Hand Orientation
- Right Hand
- Shaft Length
- 35"
- Neck Type
- Double Bend
- Face Technology
- Microhinge
- Grip Type
- Pistol
- Alignment System
- Versa Alignment
View on Amazon: Odyssey Microhinge Seven DB Putter Affiliate link
This is the Odyssey Seven putter with a double-bend neck and a 35-inch shaft. It uses the Microhinge insert for immediate topspin and forward roll. The Versa Alignment system helps with setup. The head is black with silver accents. It comes with the Odyssey Pistol grip. This model suits right-handed golfers who want a classic blade shape with modern roll technology.
Pros
- Microhinge insert delivers immediate topspin
- Versa Alignment system aids setup
- Classic Seven head shape
- Odyssey Pistol grip included
Cons
- Only available in right-hand orientation
- Standard 35-inch shaft length
- No adjustable weighting system listed
Good fit if
- You prefer a double-bend neck
- You want immediate ball roll
- You like classic blade shapes
Skip if
- You need a left-hand option
- You prefer a mallet head
- You want adjustable weight ports
Verdict: Odyssey Seven DB Microhinge Putter is a solid choice for right-handed players seeking a classic blade with a roll-focused insert. It fits golfers who trust Versa Alignment and a standard length.
TaylorMade TP Black Putter Soto #1 35"
Best for: Traditional blade feel and roll optimization
- Shaft Length
- 35"
- Head Style
- Blade
- Face Technology
- Pure Roll Insert
- Age Range
- Ages 3-5
- Hand Orientation
- Right
- Color
- Black
View on Amazon: TaylorMade TP Black Putter Soto #1 35" Affiliate link
This TaylorMade blade putter features a 35-inch shaft and a Pure Roll insert with 45-degree grooves. The insert uses soft Surlyn to optimize ball roll. Weighing 6.07 ounces, it offers a classic look with machine-milled lines. It suits golfers who prefer a traditional blade profile over the larger mallets found in other options. The black finish provides a clean aesthetic at address.
Pros
- Pure Roll insert with 45-degree downward grooves
- Blade head style for traditional feel
- 35-inch shaft length
- 6.07-ounce weight
- Machine-milled face lines
Cons
- Blade design offers less forgiveness than mallet alternatives
- No adjustable weighting system listed
- Single bend shaft configuration only
Good fit if
- You prefer a traditional blade shape
- You want a 35-inch shaft
- You value the Pure Roll insert technology
Skip if
- You need a high-MOI mallet for stability
- You require adjustable weighting options
- You prefer a center-shafted design
Verdict: TaylorMade TP Black SOTO #1 Putter fits golfers who prefer a traditional blade feel and the specific roll characteristics of the Pure Roll insert. It is a solid choice for players who prioritize a classic aesthetic and precise face technology over the stability of larger mallets.
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Putter
Best for: Right-handed golfers with a straight stroke
- Hand Orientation
- Right Hand
- Shaft Length
- 35"
- Neck Type
- Center Shafted
- Face Technology
- Speed Optimized Face Technology
- Shaft Material
- UST Mamiya All-In
- Grip Type
- Oversized Grip
View on Amazon: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Putter Affiliate link
This Cleveland Golf HB Soft 2 putter features a center-shafted design and an oversized grip. It uses an UST Mamiya All-In shaft for stability and Speed Optimized Face Technology to normalize ball speed. The 35-inch length and right-hand orientation suit specific stroke types. The black finish and 20g butt-end weight ensure consistent feel. It is a solid option for golfers seeking a straight or slight arc stroke match.
Pros
- Center shafted neck type for straight stroke alignment
- Oversized grip for enhanced stability and control
- UST Mamiya All-In shaft with carbon fiber and nanoalloys
- Speed Optimized Face Technology normalizes ball speed
- Includes 20g weight in the butt end for consistency
Cons
- Center shafted design limits toe hang options for arc strokes
- Oversized grip may feel bulky for players preferring standard sizes
- Single bend or slant neck options not available in this specific listing
Good fit if
- You prefer a center-shafted putter for a straight back-and-through stroke
- You want an oversized grip for added stability
- You are a right-handed golfer seeking a 35-inch length
Skip if
- You need a slant neck or single bend hosel for an arc stroke
- You prefer a standard grip size over an oversized one
- You are a left-handed golfer
Verdict: Cleveland Golf HB Soft 2 Center Shafted Putter offers a stable, straight-stroke solution with a UST Mamiya shaft and oversized grip. It fits right-handed players who prioritize face stability and consistent ball speed over toe hang variety.
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Putter
Best for: left-handed golfers with straight strokes
- Hand Orientation
- Left Hand
- Shaft Length
- 35"
- Neck Type
- Single Bend
- Face Technology
- Speed Optimized Face Technology
- Shaft Material
- UST Mamiya All-In
- Grip Type
- Oversized Grip
View on Amazon: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Putter Affiliate link
This Cleveland Golf HB Soft 2 Black putter features a single bend neck and an oversized grip for left-handed players. It uses a UST Mamiya All-In shaft for stability and includes Speed Optimized Face Technology to normalize ball speed across the striking area. The design targets straight or slight arc strokes. A 20g weight is included in the butt end for consistent swing feel across 35-inch and longer models.
Pros
- Single bend neck design suits straight or slight arc strokes
- Oversized grip enhances stability and control
- UST Mamiya All-In shaft provides advanced stability and stiffness
- Speed Optimized Face Technology normalizes ball speed for consistent distance
Cons
- Left-hand orientation only
- No remote or app connectivity for data tracking
- No sensor or digital display for real-time feedback
Good fit if
- You prefer a single bend neck for a straighter putting path
- You want a larger oversized grip for better hand control
- You are a left-handed golfer seeking consistent distance performance
Skip if
- You require a right-handed configuration
- You need a toe-hang design for a strong arc stroke
- You prefer a standard grip size over an oversized one
Verdict: Cleveland Golf HB Soft 2 Black Putter is a stable option for left-handed golfers with straight strokes who value consistent ball speed. The oversized grip and specialized shaft make it a solid choice for players prioritizing feel and accuracy over digital feedback.
Odyssey DFX Putter V Line Fang 35"
Best for: Right-handed golfers preferring mallet heads
- Hand Orientation
- Right Hand
- Shaft Length
- 35 Inches
- Head Style
- V Line Fang
- Grip Type
- Oversized Grip
- Age Range
- Ages 3-5
- Color
- Black
View on Amazon: Odyssey DFX Putter V Line Fang 35" Affiliate link
This Odyssey DFX putter features a V-Line Fang head with a charcoal finish and black insert. It comes with a 35-inch shaft and an oversized grip. The design highlights classic Odyssey shapes. It suits right-handed golfers seeking a mallet-style putter. The oversized grip offers stability. The charcoal finish frames the insert.
Pros
- V-Line Fang head style
- Charcoal finish with black insert
- 35-inch shaft length
- Oversized grip option
Cons
- Oversized grip may feel bulky
- Single shaft length available
- No alignment aid details listed
Good fit if
- You prefer a mallet-style head
- You want a 35-inch shaft
- You like charcoal finishes
Skip if
- You need a blade-style putter
- You prefer a pistol grip
- You play left-handed
Verdict: Odyssey DFX V-Line Fang Putter, 35" is a stable option for right-handed golfers who prefer a mallet head and a larger grip. It suits those who want a classic shape with a modern charcoal finish.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Odyssey Square to Square Jailbird 35" Putter | TaylorMade Spider X Black 35" Putter | Odyssey Microhinge Seven DB Putter | TaylorMade TP Black Putter Soto #1 35" | Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Putter | Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Putter | Odyssey DFX Putter V Line Fang 35" |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hand Orientation | Right Hand | Right Hand | Right Hand | not stated | Right Hand | Left Hand | Right Hand |
| Shaft Length | 35" | 35" | 35" | 35" | 35" | 35" | 35 Inches |
| Head Style | not stated | Spider | not stated | Blade | not stated | not stated | V Line Fang |
| Neck Type | not stated | not stated | Double Bend | not stated | Center Shafted | Single Bend | not stated |
| Face Technology | Ai-ONE Insert | not stated | Microhinge | Pure Roll Insert | Speed Optimized Face Technology | Speed Optimized Face Technology | not stated |
| Shaft Material | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | UST Mamiya All-In | UST Mamiya All-In | not stated |
| Grip Type | Oversized Grip | not stated | Pistol | not stated | Oversized Grip | Oversized Grip | Oversized Grip |
| Alignment System | not stated | Patented alignment system | Versa Alignment | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Age Range | Ages 3-5 | Ages 3-5 | Ages 3-5 | Ages 3-5 | Ages 3-5 | Ages 3-5 | Ages 3-5 |
| Color | Black | Black | Black | Black | Black | Black | Black |
| Length | 35 Inches | 35 Inches | 35 Inches | 35 Inches | 35 Inches | 35 Inches | 35 Inches |
| Weight | 1.2 pounds | 3.1 pounds | not stated | 6.07 ounces | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| Dimensions | not stated | 48 × 5 × 5 inches | 43 × 5 × 6 inches | 36 × 6 × 3.49 inches | 43 × 5 × 6 inches | 43 × 5 × 6 inches | 42 × 5 × 6 inches |
| Size | 35" Length | 35" | 35" | 35" | 35" | 35" | 35" |
| Model | 73041S3500 | N7549227 | 197193443162 | TP BLACK SOTO #1 '24 | 11241642 | HB Soft 2 Black Retreve | 73045T3501 |
Frequently asked questions
How does the TaylorMade Spider X Black compare to the Jailbird in terms of weight?
The TaylorMade Spider X Black weighs 3.1 pounds, which is much heavier than the 1.2-pound Odyssey Square to Square Jailbird. This extra mass provides greater stability for right-handed golfers. The Spider X also features a wider 5-inch width and 5-inch height, offering a different balance point than the Jailbird's design.
Is there a traditional blade option among these alternatives?
Yes, the TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 is a traditional blade putter. It weighs just 6.07 ounces and measures 36 inches in length. This model suits players who prefer a classic aesthetic and precise face technology over the stability of larger mallet heads. It features a Pure Roll insert for roll optimization.
Which putter is best for golfers who want immediate ball roll?
The Odyssey Microhinge Seven DB Putter is designed for right-handed players seeking immediate roll. It combines a classic blade shape with a roll-focused insert. The putter also includes Versa Alignment technology and comes in a standard 35-inch length. It fits golfers who trust specific face inserts to enhance their putting performance.
Can left-handed golfers find a stable option in this list?
Yes, the Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Putter is available for left-handed golfers. It offers a stable, straight-stroke solution with an oversized grip and a specialized UST Mamiya shaft. This model prioritizes face stability and consistent ball speed. It is a solid choice for players who value feel and accuracy over digital feedback.
What are the dimensions of the Cleveland HB Soft 2 Putter?
The Cleveland HB Soft 2 Putter has a width of 5 inches and a height of 6 inches. While the product attributes list a 35-inch length, the specs indicate a 43-inch length. This center-shafted design provides a stable platform for right-handed golfers with a straight stroke, focusing on consistent ball speed.
Does the Odyssey DFX V-Line Fang offer a mallet head design?
The Odyssey DFX V-Line Fang Putter features a mallet head design suitable for right-handed golfers. It includes a larger grip and a modern charcoal finish. The specs list a length of 42 inches, a width of 5 inches, and a height of 6 inches. It is a stable option for those who prefer a classic shape with modern styling.