TaylorMade Golf Spider RED Putter or TaylorMade Golf TP Black Putter? Which TaylorMade Model to Buy
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
When comparing the taylormade golf spider red putter vs golf tp black putter, you see two distinct designs from the same brand. Both models share the same shaft length and weight, and both utilize the Pure Roll insert for better forward roll. The main difference lies in their head style and materials. The Spider RED is a high-MOI mallet with a multi-material construction, while the TP Black is a machine-milled blade. You should look at the specific dimensions to find the right fit.
Key differences
| Aspect | TaylorMade Spider RED #3 34" Mallet | TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 34" Putter |
|---|---|---|
| Head Style | Mallet | Blade |
| Color | Red | Black |
| Width | 5 inches | 4 inches |
| MOI Characteristics | High MOI | not listed |
| Face Technology | Pure Roll Insert | Pure Roll Insert |
Which one should you choose?
Choose TaylorMade Spider RED #3 34" Mallet if
- You prefer a mallet design for high stability and forgiveness on off-center hits.
- You want a wider head profile that is 5 inches wide.
- You value vibration damping foam for enhanced sound and feel.
Choose TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 34" Putter if
- You prefer a traditional blade look with machine-milled lines.
- You want a narrower head profile that is 4 inches wide.
- You want a putter that is only available in right-handed orientation.
Verdict: The Spider RED suits players who want a mallet for maximum stability and forgiveness. The TP Black is better for those who prefer the look and feel of a machine-milled blade. Both share the same length and weight, so your choice depends on head shape preference.
Spider RED vs TP Black Putter
Head Style
The TaylorMade Spider RED #3 is a mallet putter, designed with a modern shape that typically appeals to golfers seeking stability. Its broad profile helps align the face at address. In contrast, the TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 is described as part of the TP Collection of blades and technical mallets, featuring flowing lines with natural curvatures. This design offers a different aesthetic and potentially a different feel at impact. The mallet style of the Spider RED focuses on high MOI, while the TP Black leans toward a more traditional or technical blade-like appearance.
Color
Color choice is a significant personal preference for many golfers. The TaylorMade Spider RED #3 features a vibrant Red finish, which can help with visibility and alignment for players who prefer high-contrast aesthetics. The TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 comes in a classic Black color, offering a more subdued and traditional look on the green. Both options are available in Right Handed orientations. Your choice between these two models will largely depend on whether you prefer the bold statement of Red or the understated elegance of Black.
Build
The construction of these putters differs notably. The Spider RED #3 uses a multi-material design, pairing a lightweight 6061 aluminum core with a heavy 304 Stainless Steel frame. This combination creates high MOI for stability. It also includes vibration-damping PU foam for better sound and feel. The TP Black Soto #1 features machine milling with flowing lines, emphasizing precision and aesthetics. Both share the Pure Roll Insert, which uses grooves at a downward 45° angle to optimize roll. The Spider RED emphasizes material contrast, while the TP Black highlights milling precision.
Size
Physical dimensions affect alignment and personal comfort. The Spider RED #3 has a width of 5 inches and a height of 6 inches, with a total length of 42 inches. The TP Black Soto #1 is slightly narrower at 4 inches wide and 35 inches high, with a listed length of 8 inches, which may refer to package dimensions or a specific part measurement. Both shafts are 34 inches. The Spider RED offers a wider profile, which can aid in stability for those who struggle with face rotation. The TP Black has a narrower width, potentially suiting players who prefer a more compact head.
Hand Orientation
Both the TaylorMade Spider RED #3 and the TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 are available in Right Handed configurations. The Spider RED also offers a Left Handed option, providing more flexibility for left-handed golfers. The TP Black Soto #1 is listed as Right Handed in the provided data, with variations showing only Right orientation. If you are a left-handed player, the Spider RED provides a direct choice. For right-handed golfers, both models are suitable, and the decision rests on other factors like head shape and aesthetic preference.
Choose Your TaylorMade Putter Model
Golfers needing maximum stability and forgiveness on off-center hits
The Spider RED #3 features a mallet head with a high MOI design. It uses a lightweight aluminum core paired with a heavy stainless steel frame to keep the face square. This multi-material construction promotes consistent roll. You benefit from vibration damping foam for better sound and feel, making it ideal for players who want help with alignment and stability.
Players who prefer a traditional blade look with modern roll tech
The TP Black Soto #1 offers a machine-milled blade design with flowing lines. It retains the Pure Roll insert with 45-degree grooves to optimize forward roll. This model appeals to golfers who like the aesthetic of a classic blade but still want the performance benefits of advanced face technology. It provides a distinct look at address while maintaining precise roll characteristics.
Those who value the specific red color and mallet shape
If you prefer the visual cue of a red mallet, this model provides a clear contrast. The 34-inch shaft length and 6.07-ounce weight match the other option, but the broad 5-inch width offers a different alignment experience. The red color helps with focus. You get the stability of a mallet design with the trusted Pure Roll insert for consistent distance control on your putts.
The products compared
TaylorMade Spider RED #3 34" Mallet
Best for: Right-handed golfers seeking stability
- Shaft Length
- 34"
- Head Style
- Mallet
- Face Technology
- Pure Roll Insert
- MOI Characteristics
- High MOI
- Hand Orientation
- Right
- Color
- Red
View on Amazon: TaylorMade Spider RED #3 34" Mallet Affiliate link
This TaylorMade Spider RED #3 is a right-handed mallet putter designed for stability. It features a 34-inch shaft and a 6061 aluminum core paired with a 304 stainless steel frame for high MOI. The Pure Roll insert promotes forward roll for better distance control. Vibration-damping PU foam improves sound and feel. It suits players seeking consistent face alignment and a smooth stroke.
Pros
- High MOI from lightweight aluminum core and heavy steel frame
- Pure Roll insert increases topspin and forward roll
- Vibration-damping PU foam enhances sound and feel
- Mallet design promotes a square face to the path
Cons
- Fixed 34-inch shaft length limits customization options
- Standard 6.07-ounce weight may feel heavy for some strokes
- No visible alignment aid specifications in provided data
Good fit if
- You prefer a high-MOI mallet for stability
- You want improved forward roll from the face
- You play with a right-handed grip
Skip if
- You require a shaft length other than 34 inches
- You prefer a lightweight blade-style putter
- You need left-handed orientation
Verdict: TaylorMade Spider RED Putter 34 inch offers high stability and consistent roll for right-handed golfers. It is a solid choice for players who value a square face alignment and a dampened feel.
TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 34" Putter
Best for: Right-handed golfers wanting a 34-inch shaft
- Hand Orientation
- Right Handed
- Shaft Length
- 34"
- Face Technology
- Pure Roll Insert
- Color
- Black
- Dimensions
- 8 × 4 × 35 inches
- Weight
- 6.07 ounces
View on Amazon: TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 34" Putter Affiliate link
The TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 is a right-handed putter with a 34-inch shaft. It features a black finish and a Pure Roll insert with 45-degree grooves to optimize roll characteristics. The head measures 4 inches wide. Machine milling provides a smooth look and feel. This model suits players seeking precise roll and a classic aesthetic for their short game.
Pros
- Pure Roll insert with 45-degree grooves for optimized roll
- Machine milled face for smooth feel
- 34-inch shaft length
- Right-handed configuration
Cons
- Only available in right-handed orientation
- No adjustable weighting mentioned in specifications
- Standard 34-inch length may not suit taller golfers
Good fit if
- You prefer a right-handed putter
- You want a 34-inch shaft length
- You value groove technology for roll
Skip if
- You need a left-handed model
- You require a longer 35-inch shaft
- You prefer a mallet over a blade design
Verdict: TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 34" Putter is a solid choice for right-handed golfers who want a 34-inch shaft and a face designed for better roll. It fits players who prioritize feel and roll over adjustability.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | TaylorMade Spider RED #3 34" Mallet | TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 34" Putter |
|---|---|---|
| Hand Orientation | not stated | Right Handed |
| Shaft Length | 34" | 34" |
| Head Style | Mallet | not stated |
| Face Technology | Pure Roll Insert | Pure Roll Insert |
| MOI Characteristics | High MOI | not stated |
| Color | Red | Black |
| Length | 34 Inches | 34 Inches |
| Dimensions | 42 × 5 × 6 inches | 8 × 4 × 35 inches |
| Weight | 6.07 ounces | 6.07 ounces |
| Size | 34" | 34" |
| Model | SPIDER RED #3 '24 | TP BLACK SOTO #1 '24 |
Frequently asked questions
Which TaylorMade putter is better for right-handed golfers?
Both the Spider RED #3 and the TP Black Soto #1 are designed for right-handed golfers. The Spider RED #3 offers a mallet shape for stability, while the TP Black Soto #1 provides a different head profile. You should choose based on whether you prefer the broader alignment aids of the mallet or the specific feel of the Soto model.
Do these putters have the same length?
Yes, both models share the same shaft length of 34 inches. This standard length suits most golfers who do not need a longer or shorter putter. The consistent length ensures that your posture and putting stroke mechanics remain similar regardless of which head style you select from the TaylorMade lineup.
What is the weight difference between the two putters?
There is no weight difference between the two models. Both the Spider RED #3 and the TP Black Soto #1 weigh 6.07 ounces. This identical weight allows you to maintain a consistent feel in your hands. You can switch between the mallet and the Soto head without adjusting your grip pressure or swing tempo.
How wide is the Spider RED putter head?
The TaylorMade Spider RED #3 has a head width of 5 inches. This wider profile contributes to its mallet design, which helps with face stability at address. The increased width typically aids in straightening the putter face, making it a practical choice for golfers who struggle with face rotation during their stroke.
Is the TP Black Soto putter also a mallet?
The TP Black Soto #1 has a width of 4 inches, which is narrower than the Spider RED. While it may share some mallet characteristics, its narrower profile distinguishes it from the broader Spider RED design. This difference in width affects the overall look and potentially the alignment preferences for right-handed players.
Which putter offers better alignment aids?
The Spider RED #3 features a broad mallet profile that typically provides strong alignment aids. Its 5-inch width and square face alignment help you set up consistently. The TP Black Soto #1, with its 4-inch width, offers a different visual profile. You should test both to see which head shape helps you square the face more easily.