6 Best Alternatives to the TaylorMade Golf Spider Tour Black (2026)

Comparing alternatives to Spider Tour

Odyssey Square 2 Square 34" Double Wide

The Odyssey Square 2 Square Double Wide Putter uses an AI-designed face to promote consistent ball speed. While the TaylorMade Spider Tour Black offers high-MOI stability, this Odyssey model prioritizes face stability for off-center hits. It shares the 34-inch length and right-handed orientation but features a distinct square head shape rather than the classic Spider silhouette. The width is slightly narrower at 5 inches compared to the TaylorMade's 6-inch profile. This putter suits players who value modern technology and a secure grip feel over traditional aesthetics. If you want a black finish with a focus on speed consistency, this is a strong alternative.

Odyssey Microhinge Putter 34" Double Wide

The Odyssey Microhinge Double Wide Putter is designed for right-handed golfers seeking immediate topspin. It features the Microhinge insert for better roll and Versa Alignment for aiming clarity. Like the TaylorMade Spider Tour Black, it is available in a 34-inch length and black color. The head width is 5 inches, which is narrower than the 6-inch width of the Spider Tour. This model appeals to players who prioritize roll quality and a pistol grip feel. It offers a solid double-wide head design that differs from the traditional mallet shape of the TaylorMade. Choose this if you want a budget-friendly option with proven face technology for consistent starts.

TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 34" Putter

The TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 Putter delivers consistent roll through its grooved insert. It is a mallet design suited for right-handed players who favor stability. This model shares the 34-inch length and black color with the Spider Tour Black. However, it has a narrower 4-inch width compared to the 6-inch width of the Spider Tour. The weight is listed as 6.07 ounces, which is significantly lighter than the 1.2-pound Spider Tour. This difference in mass affects the feel and swing weight. If you prefer a lighter mallet with a specific insert for roll, this Soto model is a viable alternative within the TaylorMade lineup.

Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #11 Putter, 34"

The Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Putter suits left-handed golfers with straight or slight arc strokes. This is a key difference from the right-handed TaylorMade Spider Tour Black. It features face technology and an oversized grip for stability. The putter is available in a 34-inch length and black color. The head width is 5 inches, which is narrower than the 6-inch Spider Tour. This model does not offer right-hand configurations, making it exclusive to left-handed players. If you are a lefty seeking a stable mallet with advanced face tech, this Cleveland option provides a solid alternative. It prioritizes feel and grip stability over adjustable shaft lengths.

Cleveland Retreve HB Soft 2 Putter 34"

The Cleveland Retreve HB Soft 2 Putter delivers stable feel and consistent distance for straight or slight arc strokes. Like the Spider Tour Black, it is available in a 34-inch length and black color. The head width is 5 inches, narrower than the 6-inch Spider Tour. It shares the 1.2-pound weight with the TaylorMade model, offering a similar mass for stability. This putter prioritizes face technology and grip stability over adjustable shaft lengths. It is a solid choice for players who value a consistent roll and solid feel. If you prefer a mallet with a slightly narrower profile but similar weight, this Cleveland model is a practical alternative.

TaylorMade Spider RED #3 34" Mallet

The TaylorMade Spider RED #3 Putter delivers stability and roll for right-handed golfers who prefer a mallet design. It shares the 34-inch length and right-handed orientation with the Spider Tour Black. The primary difference is the color; this model is red, while the original is black. The head width is 5 inches, narrower than the 6-inch Spider Tour. It weighs 6.07 ounces, which is much lighter than the 1.2-pound Spider Tour. This weight difference affects the swing feel and balance. If you want the same stability and alignment features but in a lighter, red package, this Spider RED model is a suitable alternative.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter #3 34"

Best for: right-handed golfers seeking stability

Hand Orientation

Right Hand

Shaft Length

34 Inches

Head Style

Spider Tour #3

Alignment System

patented alignment system

MOI Characteristics

high-MOI

Color

Black

View on Amazon: TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter #3 34" Affiliate link

This TaylorMade Spider Tour #3 putter offers high-MOI stability for consistent strokes. It features a patented alignment system for visual clarity and TSS weights for balanced performance. The black PVD-coated head includes copper accents. Weighing 1.2 pounds with a 34-inch shaft, it suits right-handed golfers seeking forgiveness and a classic look on the green.

Pros

• High-MOI head design for stability
• Patented alignment system for visual clarity
• TSS weights for balanced weighting
• Durable PVD coating with copper accents

Cons

• Only available in right-hand orientation
• Standard 34-inch shaft length
• Single model style option

Good fit if

• You want high-MOI forgiveness
• You prefer right-handed putters
• You value visual alignment aids

Skip if

• You need a left-handed putter
• You prefer a different shaft length
• You want a different head style

Verdict: TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter delivers stability for right-handed players. It fits golfers who prioritize alignment aids and a classic black finish.

2 Best premium

Odyssey Square 2 Square 34" Double Wide

Best for: Players seeking face stability and consistent ball speed

Hand Orientation

Right Hand

Shaft Length

34"

Face Technology

Ai-ONE Insert

Grip Type

Oversized Grip

Color

Black

Dimensions

43 × 5 × 6 inches

View on Amazon: Odyssey Square 2 Square 34" Double Wide Affiliate link

This Odyssey putter features a double-wide head measuring 5 inches wide and 6 inches high. It uses an Ai-ONE insert with an aluminum backer to promote consistent ball speed across the face. The modern center shafted design aligns above the center of gravity to promote a square face throughout your stroke. It includes a built-in forward press to reduce face opening. You get an oversized grip for a secure feel and a navy blue PVD finish.

Pros

• Ai-ONE insert with aluminum backer for consistent ball speed
• Double-wide head design at 5 inches wide
• Center shafted design promotes a square face
• Built-in forward press reduces face opening
• Oversized grip for secure control

Cons

• Double-wide head may feel too large for some stroke types
• Center shaft design limits traditional blade aesthetics
• Only available in right-hand orientation

Good fit if

• You want a putter with a double-wide head for stability
• You prefer a center-shafted design for face alignment
• You like an oversized grip for control

Skip if

• You prefer a traditional blade-style putter
• You need a left-handed option
• You dislike a large head profile

Verdict: Odyssey Square to Square Double Wide Putter offers a stable, AI-designed face for consistent speed. It suits players who value a square face and a secure grip over traditional aesthetics.

3 Also great

Odyssey Microhinge Putter 34" Double Wide

Best for: Right-handed players wanting immediate topspin

Hand Orientation

Right

Shaft Length

34"

Head Style

Double Wide

Neck Type

Double Bend

Face Technology

Microhinge insert

Grip Type

Odyssey Pistol Grip

View on Amazon: Odyssey Microhinge Putter 34" Double Wide Affiliate link

This right-handed putter features a 34-inch double bend shaft and a double wide head style. It uses the Microhinge insert for immediate topspin and forward roll. The Versa Alignment system aids aiming with a silver and black look. You get the popular Odyssey Pistol grip. It suits players seeking classic head shapes and reliable roll characteristics.

Pros

• Microhinge insert delivers immediate topspin
• Versa Alignment system for clear aiming
• Double wide head style for stability
• Odyssey Pistol grip for comfort

Cons

• Only available in right-hand orientation in this listing
• No remote or app connectivity
• Double bend neck limits neck style options

Good fit if

• You prefer a double wide head shape
• You want immediate topspin on putts
• You like the Odyssey Pistol grip

Skip if

• You are a left-handed player
• You need a slant neck or crank hosel
• You prefer a single bend shaft

Verdict: Odyssey Microhinge Double Wide Putter is a solid choice for right-handed golfers who value the Microhinge insert for roll and Versa Alignment for aiming. It fits players who like the double wide head and pistol grip.

4 Also great

TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 34" Putter

Best for: Right-handed golfers seeking pure roll

Hand Orientation

Right Handed

Shaft Length

34"

Face Technology

Pure Roll Insert

Color

Black

Dimensions

8 × 4 × 35 inches

Weight

6.07 ounces

View on Amazon: TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 34" Putter Affiliate link

This TaylorMade mallet features a 34-inch shaft and weighs 6.07 ounces. It uses a Pure Roll insert with 45-degree grooves to optimize ball roll. The black finish and machine-milled face offer a clean look at address. It is designed for right-handed golfers who prefer a technical mallet. The specific SOTO #1 head shape suits players seeking stability and consistent rollout.

Pros

• Pure Roll insert with 45-degree grooves
• Machine-milled face for precise look
• 34-inch shaft length
• 6.07-ounce head weight

Cons

• Only available in right-handed orientation
• Single head shape option (SOTO #1)
• No adjustable weighting system listed

Good fit if

• You want a mallet with a pure roll insert
• You prefer a right-handed putter
• You like a black, machine-milled finish

Skip if

• You need a left-handed model
• You prefer a blade-style putter
• You require adjustable weight ports

Verdict: TaylorMade TP Black SOTO #1 Putter delivers consistent roll through its grooved insert and suits right-handed players who favor a stable mallet design.

5 Best budget

Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #11 Putter, 34"

Best for: left-handed golfers with straight strokes

Hand Orientation

Left Hand

Shaft Length

34"

Neck Type

Single Bend

Face Technology

Speed Optimized Face Technology

Shaft Material

UST Mamiya All-In

Grip Type

Oversized Grip

View on Amazon: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #11 Putter, 34" Affiliate link

This left-handed putter features a 34-inch UST Mamiya All-In shaft and a single-bend neck. The face uses Speed Optimized Face Technology to normalize ball speed across an enlarged striking area. It includes an oversized grip for stability. The model is designed for straight or slight arc stroke types, syncing the hosel and toe hang to your swing.

Pros

• UST Mamiya All-In shaft with carbon fiber and nanoalloys for stiffness
• Speed Optimized Face Technology normalizes ball speed
• Oversized grip enhances stability
• Designed for straight or slight arc strokes

Cons

• Left-hand orientation only
• Single-bend neck limits stroke customization
• No remote or app connectivity

Good fit if

• You use a straight or slight arc putting stroke
• You prefer a left-handed putter
• You want a single-bend neck design

Skip if

• You are right-handed
• You need a center-shafted or slant-neck model
• You prefer a silver color option

Verdict: Cleveland Golf HB Soft 2 Black Putter suits left-handed golfers with straight or slight arc strokes who value face technology and an oversized grip. It is a solid alternative for those who do not require right-hand or different neck configurations.

6 Also great

Cleveland Retreve HB Soft 2 Putter 34"

Best for: Straight or slight arc stroke players

Hand Orientation

Right Hand

Shaft Length

34"

Neck Type

Single Bend

Face Technology

Speed Optimized Face Technology

Shaft Material

UST Mamiya All-In

Grip Type

Oversized Grip

View on Amazon: Cleveland Retreve HB Soft 2 Putter 34" Affiliate link

The Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black is a right-handed putter with a single bend neck and 34-inch shaft. It uses a UST Mamiya All-In shaft for stability and features Speed Optimized Face Technology to normalize ball speed. The oversized grip and 20g butt weight help manage swing feel. This model suits players seeking consistent distance and straight or slight arc strokes.

Pros

• UST Mamiya All-In shaft with carbon fiber and nanoalloys for stiffness
• Speed Optimized Face Technology normalizes ball speed across the striking area
• Oversized grip for enhanced stability
• 20g weight included in the butt end for consistent swing feel

Cons

• Single bend neck limits stroke customization options
• Fixed 34-inch shaft length
• Right-hand orientation only

Good fit if

• You prefer a single bend neck for straight or slight arc strokes
• You want an oversized grip for stability
• You value consistent ball speed across the face

Skip if

• You need a left-handed option
• You prefer a mid-mallet or smaller head size
• You require multiple shaft length choices

Verdict: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black 34" Putter delivers stable feel and consistent distance for players with straight or slight arc strokes. It is a solid choice for those who prioritize face technology and grip stability over adjustable shaft lengths.

7 Best red

TaylorMade Spider RED #3 34" Mallet

Best for: Right-handed golfers seeking stability

Shaft Length

34"

Head Style

Mallet

Face Technology

Pure Roll Insert

MOI Characteristics

High MOI

Hand Orientation

Right

Color

Red

View on Amazon: TaylorMade Spider RED #3 34" Mallet Affiliate link

This is a right-handed mallet putter with a 34-inch shaft. It features a high MOI design using a lightweight aluminum core and stainless steel frame. The Pure Roll insert promotes forward roll for better distance control. Vibration-damping foam improves sound and feel. The red color offers high visibility. It suits golfers seeking stability and consistent roll.

Pros

• High MOI for stability
• Pure Roll insert for forward roll
• Vibration-damping foam for feel
• Lightweight aluminum core

Cons

• Fixed 34-inch shaft length
• Right-hand orientation only
• Mallet head may not suit all strokes

Good fit if

• You prefer a high MOI mallet putter
• You want improved forward roll
• You like a red club for visibility

Skip if

• You need a left-handed putter
• You prefer a blade-style head
• You require adjustable length

Verdict: TaylorMade Spider RED #3 Putter delivers stability and roll for right-handed golfers who prefer a mallet design. It is a solid choice for players prioritizing consistency over adjustability.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions

See also

• black decker black decker 20v alternatives
• sndoas black range alternatives