6 Best Alternatives to the Cleveland Golf Retreve HB Soft 2 (2026)

How each alternative compares

Cleveland HB Soft 2 Center Shaft Putter

The Cleveland HB Soft 2 Center Shaft Putter keeps the same 35-inch length and silver finish as the original, but swaps the single-bend neck for a center-shaft design. This change alters the toe hang, offering a different feel for straight-stroke players. Both models share the same Speed Optimized Face Technology to normalize ball speed across the striking area. You lose the unique ball-picking feature of the Retreve head shape, but gain the stability of a center-shafted mallet. If you prefer a neutral balance point over the slight toe hang of the single-bend version, this is the logical step within the same brand family. It targets the same right-handed users seeking consistency without changing the overall weight or grip style.

Wilson Infinite Bucktown Putter, 35", Left Hand

The Wilson Infinite Bucktown Putter shifts focus to left-handed golfers, a key difference from the original right-hand-only Cleveland model. It features a slightly narrower head at 4.6 inches wide compared to the Cleveland’s 5-inch width. The weight is higher at 1.38 pounds versus the Cleveland’s 1.2 pounds, providing a heavier feel. This model emphasizes alignment aids and a consistent roll for left-handers who want a mallet design. You give up the oversized grip and the specific ball-picking feature of the Cleveland Retreve. However, you gain a dedicated left-hand option with a distinct black and red color scheme. It is a solid choice for left-handed players who value alignment help and a slightly heavier mallet over the specific stroke-synced hosel of the Cleveland.

Odyssey Square to Square Jailbird 35" Putter

The Odyssey Square to Square Jailbird 35" Putter offers a premium alternative with an AI-optimized face insert, differing from the Cleveland’s dynamic groove milling. It maintains the 35-inch length and right-hand orientation but uses a black finish instead of silver. The head shape is a stable mallet design suited for forward press setups. You trade the unique Retreve ball-picking feature and the oversized grip for a different alignment system and face technology focused on AI precision. The weight remains similar at 1.2 pounds. This putter is ideal for right-handed golfers who prioritize advanced face performance and stability over the specific stroke-synced hosel styles of the Cleveland HB Soft 2. It suits those who do not need left-hand or lighter head options.

Cobra Classic Mallet Putter 34"

The Cobra Classic Mallet Putter 34" differs significantly in length, offering a 34-inch shaft instead of the 35-inch standard found in the original Cleveland model. It features a steel shaft for a traditional feel, contrasting with the Cleveland’s likely different shaft composition. The weight is 1.38 pounds, heavier than the Cleveland’s 1.2 pounds. This model provides a stable mallet design with a simple sightline, prioritizing traditional feel over adjustable features. You give up the oversized grip and the Speed Optimized Face Technology of the Cleveland. However, you gain a straightforward alignment system and a steel-shafted construction. It fits golfers who want a shorter, heavier mallet with a classic feel rather than the specific stroke-specific hosel and grip combination of the Cleveland Retreve.

Odyssey DFX Putter V Line Fang 35"

The Odyssey DFX V Line Fang Putter 35" shares the 35-inch length and right-hand orientation with the original Cleveland but features a black finish. It offers a different head shape with V Line Fang alignment, distinct from the Retreve’s ball-picking design. The weight is not explicitly listed in the provided data, but the head shape is designed for stability. You lose the oversized grip and the specific Speed Optimized Face Technology of the Cleveland. Instead, you gain a classic Odyssey mallet shape with modern stability features. This putter suits right-handers who value the V Line Fang alignment and a stable mallet feel over the unique head configuration and grip style of the Cleveland HB Soft 2. It is a solid choice for those seeking traditional Odyssey aesthetics with enhanced stability.

TaylorMade Spider RED Putter #3 35"

The TaylorMade Spider RED Putter #3 35" offers a distinct red color and a high MOI mallet design compared to the silver Cleveland model. It shares the 35-inch length and right-hand orientation. The weight is 6.07 ounces, which is significantly lighter than the Cleveland’s 1.2 pounds. This model focuses on consistent face alignment and improved roll through its high stability head shape. You give up the oversized grip and the unique ball-picking feature of the Retreve. However, you gain a bold red aesthetic and a different stability profile. It is ideal for right-handed golfers who need high MOI stability and do not mind a lighter head weight. The Spider RED suits players seeking consistent face alignment over the specific stroke-synced hosel and grip combination of the Cleveland.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Cleveland Retreve HB Soft 2 35" Putter

Best for: Right-handed golfers with straight strokes

Hand Orientation

Right Hand

Shaft Length

35 inches

Neck Type

Single Bend

Face Technology

Speed Optimized Face Technology

Grip Type

Oversized Grip

Age Range

Ages 3-5

View on Amazon: Cleveland Retreve HB Soft 2 35" Putter Affiliate link

This oversized mallet putter features a 35-inch shaft and single bend neck, designed for straight or slight arc strokes. It uses Speed Optimized Face Technology to normalize ball speed across an enlarged striking area. The unique Retreve head shape allows you to pick the ball out of the hole easily. It includes an oversized grip and a 20g weight in the butt end for consistent feel.

Pros

• Speed Optimized Face Technology normalizes ball speed for consistent distance
• Retreve head shape lets you pick the ball out of the hole
• Oversized grip aids stability and control
• 20g weight in the butt end ensures consistent swing feel

Cons

• Only available in right-hand orientation
• Limited shaft length options of 34 or 35 inches
• Single bend neck restricts toe hang for strong arc strokes

Good fit if

• You prefer a straight or slight arc putting stroke
• You want an oversized mallet head for stability
• You need a 35-inch shaft length

Skip if

• You require a left-hand configuration
• You prefer a mid-mallet or blade style
• You need a shaft length shorter than 34 inches

Verdict: Cleveland Golf Retreve HB Soft 2 Putter fits right-handed golfers who want an oversized mallet with a unique ball-picking feature. It suits those using a straight stroke who value consistent ball speed across the face.

2 Also great

Cleveland HB Soft 2 Center Shaft Putter

Best for: Straight stroke players seeking consistency

Hand Orientation

Right Hand

Shaft Length

35"

Face Technology

Speed Optimized Face

Grip Type

Oversized Grip

Age Range

Ages 3-5

Color

Silver

View on Amazon: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Center Shaft Putter Affiliate link

This Cleveland HB Soft 2 putter features a center-shafted mallet design with a 35-inch length. It utilizes Speed Optimized Face Technology to normalize ball speed across an enlarged striking area. The model includes a 20g weight in the butt end for consistent swing feel. It is suitable for golfers seeking a straight or slight arc stroke style with a silver finish and oversized grip.

Pros

• Speed Optimized Face Technology normalizes ball speed.
• Center shafted mallet design for straight strokes.
• Includes 20g butt-end weight for consistent feel.
• Oversized grip for enhanced control.

Cons

• Only available in silver or black finishes.
• Limited to straight or slight arc stroke types.
• No adjustable weighting system mentioned in specs.

Good fit if

• You prefer a center-shafted mallet putter.
• You want a 35-inch shaft length.
• You need consistent distance performance on off-center hits.

Skip if

• You require a toe-hang putter for a strong arc stroke.
• You prefer a single-bend shaft configuration.
• You need a putter with adjustable weighting options.

Verdict: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Center Shaft Putter suits players who favor a straight stroke and want predictable distance. The center-shafted mallet design and face technology provide stability and consistency for this specific stroke type.

3 Best budget

Wilson Infinite Bucktown Putter, 35", Left Hand

Best for: left-handed golfers seeking alignment help

Hand Orientation

Left Hand

Shaft Length

35"

Face Technology

Double-Milled Face

Target Audience

Men

Age Range

Ages 3-5

Dimensions

38.7 × 4.6 × 4.6 inches

View on Amazon: Wilson Infinite Bucktown Putter, 35", Left Hand Affiliate link

This Wilson Infinite Bucktown putter is designed for left-handed men. It features a 35-inch shaft and a double-milled face for consistent roll. The PVD anti-glare finish reduces visual distraction. Thick parallel alignment lines help with focus. The mallet head measures 4.6 by 4.6 inches. It offers a straightforward build for players seeking reliable distance control.

Pros

• Double-milled face for consistent feel and roll
• 35-inch shaft length for standard reach
• PVD anti-glare finish reduces distraction
• Parallel alignment lines aid focus

Cons

• Left-hand orientation only
• Heavier build at 1.38 pounds
• No adjustable weighting system mentioned

Good fit if

• You are a left-handed golfer
• You prefer a mallet-style putter
• You want anti-glare features

Skip if

• You are right-handed
• You need a lighter putter
• You want right-hand options

Verdict: Wilson Infinite Bucktown 35" Left-Hand Putter suits left-handed players who value alignment aids and a consistent roll. It is a solid choice for those who prefer a heavier mallet design.

4 Best premium

Odyssey Square to Square Jailbird 35" Putter

Best for: Right-handed golfers wanting AI insert stability

Hand Orientation

Right Hand

Shaft Length

35"

Face Technology

Ai-ONE Insert

Grip Type

Oversized Grip

Age Range

Ages 3-5

Color

Black

View on Amazon: Odyssey Square to Square Jailbird 35" Putter Affiliate link

This is a right-hand, center-shafted mallet putter with a 35-inch length and a 1.2-pound weight. It features an Ai-ONE insert for consistent ball speed and a forward press design to square the face. The oversized grip and navy blue PVD finish offer a premium look. It suits players seeking a modern, stable putter with AI-optimized face performance.

Pros

• Ai-ONE insert with aluminum backer for consistent ball speed
• Modern center shafted design with built-in forward press
• Oversized grip for a secure, controlled feel
• SL 180 shafts tailored for balanced performance

Cons

• Only available in right-hand orientation
• Fixed 35-inch length limits customization for some strokes
• Heavy 1.2-pound head may not suit light swing speeds

Good fit if

• You prefer a center-shafted mallet design
• You want an insert that promotes consistent ball speed
• You like a forward press setup to reduce face opening

Skip if

• You need a left-hand option
• You prefer a traditional blade or toe-hang putter
• You want a lighter head weight under 1.2 pounds

Verdict: Odyssey Jailbird Putter, 35" is a solid choice for right-handed golfers who value AI-optimized face performance and a stable mallet design. It fits players who prefer a forward press setup and do not need left-hand or lighter head options.

5 Also great

Cobra Classic Mallet Putter 34"

Best for: Golfers wanting a stable steel shaft mallet

Shaft Length

34

Shaft Material

Steel

Alignment System

Single Sightline

Color

Silver

Weight

1.38 pounds

View on Amazon: Cobra Classic Mallet Putter 34" Affiliate link

This Cobra mallet putter features a 34-inch steel shaft and a single sightline alignment system. The CNC-machined face delivers a soft feel and clean sound at impact. Weighing 1.38 pounds, it offers a stable head for a smooth stroke. It suits golfers who prefer a traditional steel shaft setup with clear visual guidance for consistent aiming.

Pros

• CNC-machined face for precision and consistent soft feel
• Single sightline alignment for confident setup
• Traditional steel shaft for inherent stability
• Mallet head design for steady impact

Cons

• Shorter 34-inch length compared to standard 35-inch options
• Fixed single sightline limits complex alignment preferences
• No adjustable weighting or modular components listed

Good fit if

• You prefer a traditional steel shaft for stability
• You want a mallet head with a simple sightline
• You are comfortable with a 34-inch putter length

Skip if

• You require a 35-inch shaft length
• You need multiple alignment sightlines or options
• You prefer a blade-style head over a mallet

Verdict: Cobra Classic Mallet Putter 34" provides a stable, steel-shafted mallet option with a simple sightline. It fits golfers who prioritize traditional feel and straightforward alignment over adjustable features or longer lengths.

6 Also great

Odyssey DFX Putter V Line Fang 35"

Best for: Right-handers wanting mallet stability

Hand Orientation

Right Hand

Shaft Length

35 Inches

Head Style

V Line Fang

Grip Type

Oversized Grip

Age Range

Ages 3-5

Color

Black

View on Amazon: Odyssey DFX Putter V Line Fang 35" Affiliate link

The Odyssey DFX is a right-hand mallet-style putter featuring a V Line Fang head shape. It comes in a 35-inch length with a charcoal finish and a black insert. The club includes an oversized grip for enhanced stability. This model is designed for players who prefer a classic Odyssey head profile with modern alignment aids. It suits those seeking a stable, high-MOI putter for consistent putting performance.

Pros

• V Line Fang head shape for alignment
• 35-inch shaft length
• Oversized grip included
• Charcoal finish with black insert

Cons

• Oversized grip may feel too heavy for some
• Right-hand only configuration
• No adjustable weighting system listed

Good fit if

• You prefer a mallet-style putter for stability
• You want a 35-inch putter length
• You like the V Line Fang alignment aid

Skip if

• You are a left-handed golfer
• You prefer a blade-style putter
• You need a lighter grip option

Verdict: Odyssey DFX V Line Fang Putter is a stable mallet putter for right-handers who value the V Line Fang alignment and oversized grip. It fits players seeking a classic Odyssey head shape with modern stability features.

7 Best red

TaylorMade Spider RED Putter #3 35"

Best for: right-handed golfers needing stability

Shaft Length

35"

Head Style

Mallet

Face Technology

Pure Roll Insert

MOI Characteristics

High MOI

Age Range

Ages 3-5

Hand Orientation

Right

View on Amazon: TaylorMade Spider RED Putter #3 35" Affiliate link

This mallet putter uses a multi-material design with a lightweight aluminum core and stainless steel frame. The 35-inch shaft and high MOI promote stability. The Pure Roll insert increases topspin for better forward roll. Vibration damping foam improves sound and feel. It suits right-handed golfers seeking consistent face alignment and distance control.

Pros

• High MOI from aluminum core and steel frame
• Pure Roll insert increases topspin
• Vibration damping foam for better feel
• 35-inch shaft length

Cons

• Only available in Red or White colors
• Standard 35-inch length only
• Right-hand orientation only

Good fit if

• You want high MOI stability
• You prefer a mallet head
• You need a 35-inch shaft

Skip if

• You need left-hand orientation
• You prefer a blade style
• You want custom length options

Verdict: TaylorMade Spider RED 35" Putter offers high MOI stability for right-handed golfers who want a mallet head with a 35-inch shaft. It suits players seeking consistent face alignment and improved roll.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions