TaylorMade Golf TP Black Putter Alternatives: 6 Similar Picks Compared
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are looking for taylormade golf tp black putter alternatives that match specific performance needs. The TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 features a 34-inch shaft and a 6.07-ounce head with a Pure Roll insert for consistent ball roll. This machine-milled design offers a classic look with downward 45° grooves to optimize roll characteristics. It is a precise tool for right-handed golfers who prefer a specific weight and length.
However, you might need a different spec, size, feature, or brand for your game. Some players seek more stability, while others want a distinct aesthetic or a different grip profile. The 6 alternatives on this list were chosen because their specs overlap with the original. You will find options ranging from high-MOI mallets to double-wide designs. Each pick shares key attributes like a 34-inch length or a black finish. This ensures you can find a club that fits your stroke and visual preference without compromising on essential dimensions.
Our top pick: TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 34" Putter.
Comparing Alternative Putter Specs
Odyssey Square 2 Square 34" Double Wide
The Odyssey Square to Square Double Wide offers a wider 5-inch head compared to the TaylorMade TP Black Soto's 4-inch width. This design prioritizes face stability and forgiveness on off-center hits. It uses a center-shafted configuration, which differs from the toe-hang or face-balanced dynamics often found in blade-style putters. The oversized grip enhances control, making it suitable for players who struggle with face rotation. While it lacks the Pure Roll insert's specific 45-degree groove technology, it provides a modern, stable alternative for right-handed golfers seeking consistency without the narrow profile of a blade.
TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter #3 34"
The TaylorMade Spider Tour Black #3 is a mallet design with a significantly wider 6-inch head, offering higher MOI stability than the narrow 4-inch Soto blade. It weighs 1.2 pounds, providing a heavier feel compared to the 6.07-ounce Soto head. This model emphasizes forgiveness and clear alignment for players who prefer a mallet aesthetic. It shares the 34-inch shaft length but sacrifices the precise machine-milled look and Pure Roll insert of the Soto for maximum stability. It is ideal for golfers who want a stable, high-MOI option that minimizes twisting on mishits.
Odyssey Microhinge Putter 34" Double Wide
The Odyssey Microhinge Double Wide features a 5-inch wide head, offering more forgiveness than the 4-inch TaylorMade Soto. It utilizes a Microhinge insert designed to lift the ball quickly and reduce skid, differing from the Soto's Pure Roll insert. The Double Wide design provides enhanced stability for face control. It includes Versa Alignment technology and a classic Pistol grip, catering to right-handed players who value roll characteristics and head stability. While it lacks the machine-milled finish of the Soto, it offers a reliable, stable alternative with a focus on consistent ball speed and alignment aid.
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #11 Putter, 34"
The Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #11 is designed for left-handed golfers, unlike the right-handed TaylorMade Soto. It features a 5-inch wide head and an oversized grip, providing stability for straight or slight arc strokes. It weighs 1.2 pounds, offering a heavier feel compared to the lighter Soto head. This putter prioritizes a stable, consistent performance for players who prefer a black aesthetic and a mallet-style design. It lacks the Pure Roll insert and machine-milled finish of the Soto but serves as a solid option for left-handers seeking forgiveness and a stable grip experience.
Cleveland Retreve HB Soft 2 Putter 34"
The Cleveland Retreve HB Soft 2 Putter is another left-handed option with a 5-inch wide head and 1.2-pound weight, contrasting with the right-handed, 6.07-ounce TaylorMade Soto. It features a single bend neck and an oversized grip, favoring stability over adjustability. This model suits players with straight or slight arc strokes who want consistent performance. It lacks the Pure Roll insert and the specific machine-milled aesthetic of the Soto. Instead, it offers a stable, forgiving design with a focus on reliable roll and a comfortable grip, making it a practical choice for left-handed golfers prioritizing stability.
TaylorMade Spider RED #3 34" Mallet
The TaylorMade Spider Red #3 is a mallet putter with a 5-inch width, offering more forgiveness than the 4-inch Soto blade. It weighs 6.07 ounces, matching the Soto's head weight but distributing it differently for higher MOI stability. It features a dampened feel and consistent roll, appealing to right-handed golfers who prioritize forgiveness. The red color distinguishes it visually from the black Soto. While it shares the 34-inch shaft length, it sacrifices the blade-style look and Pure Roll insert for a stable, high-MOI mallet design that minimizes twisting on off-center hits.
Quick picks
Our 7 picks
TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 34" Putter
Best for: Right-handed golfers seeking pure roll
- Hand Orientation
- Right Handed
- Shaft Length
- 34"
- Face Technology
- Pure Roll Insert
- Color
- Black
- Dimensions
- 8 × 4 × 35 inches
- Weight
- 6.07 ounces
View on Amazon: TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 34" Putter Affiliate link
This TaylorMade TP Black SOTO #1 putter features a 34-inch shaft and a 6.07-ounce head. It includes a Pure Roll insert with 45-degree grooves to optimize roll. The black finish and machine-milled face offer a clean look. It is designed for right-handed golfers seeking precision and consistent ball roll.
Pros
- Pure Roll insert with 45-degree grooves
- Machine-milled face for consistent feel
- 34-inch shaft length
- 6.07-ounce head weight
Cons
- Only available in right-handed orientation
- Single size option listed
- No adjustable weighting system mentioned
Good fit if
- You prefer a right-handed putter
- You want a 34-inch shaft
- You value pure roll technology
Skip if
- You need a left-handed model
- You require adjustable weighting
- You prefer a different shaft length
Verdict: TaylorMade TP Black SOTO #1 Putter suits right-handed golfers who prioritize a 34-inch shaft and a 6.07-ounce head with a Pure Roll insert for consistent ball roll.
Odyssey Square 2 Square 34" Double Wide
Best for: Right-handed players seeking face stability
- Hand Orientation
- Right Hand
- Shaft Length
- 34"
- Face Technology
- Ai-ONE Insert
- Grip Type
- Oversized Grip
- Color
- Black
- Dimensions
- 43 × 5 × 6 inches
View on Amazon: Odyssey Square 2 Square 34" Double Wide Affiliate link
This Odyssey putter uses a modern center-shafted design to align with the center of gravity, promoting a square face through the stroke. It features an Ai-ONE insert with an aluminum backer and White Hot urethane layer for consistent ball speed and classic feel. The oversized grip offers control, while the navy blue PVD finish provides a premium look. It is ideal for players seeking stability and forgiveness on the green.
Pros
- Ai-ONE insert with aluminum backer for consistent ball speed
- Center shafted design promotes a square face throughout the stroke
- Built-in forward shaft lean reduces face opening
- Oversized grip for a secure and controlled feel
Cons
- Only available in right-hand orientation
- Double wide head may feel bulky for some stroke types
- Limited to single bend configuration in listed options
Good fit if
- You want a center-shafted putter for face stability
- You prefer an oversized grip for control
- You like the classic White Hot feel
Skip if
- You play left-handed
- You prefer a traditional blade-style head
- You need multiple bend configurations
Verdict: Odyssey Square to Square Double Wide Putter is a stable, forgiving option for right-handed golfers who value a square face and consistent speed. It suits players who prefer a modern center-shafted design and an oversized grip for enhanced control.
TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter #3 34"
Best for: Golfers seeking high-MOI mallet stability
- Hand Orientation
- Right Hand
- Shaft Length
- 34 Inches
- Head Style
- Spider Tour #3
- Alignment System
- patented alignment system
- MOI Characteristics
- high-MOI
- Color
- Black
View on Amazon: TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter #3 34" Affiliate link
The TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter is a right-handed, 34-inch mallet designed for high-MOI stability. Its distinctive shape offers forgiveness on off-center hits, while the patented alignment system provides clear visual cues for your line. The PVD coating and copper accents give it a premium black finish. This putter suits golfers seeking consistency and a classic, recognizable aesthetic on the greens.
Pros
- High-MOI head design for stability and forgiveness
- Patented alignment system for visual clarity
- Durable PVD coating with copper accents
- TSS weights for balanced performance
Cons
- Mallet shape may not suit stroke-style putters
- 34-inch length limits reach for taller players
- No adjustable weighting settings mentioned
Good fit if
- You prefer a high-MOI mallet design
- You want clear visual alignment aids
- You play with a right-handed grip
Skip if
- You need a left-handed option
- You prefer a blade-style putter
- You require adjustable weighting
Verdict: TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter delivers reliable stability for golfers who value forgiveness and clear alignment. It is a solid choice for players who prefer a mallet head and a 34-inch shaft.
Odyssey Microhinge Putter 34" Double Wide
Best for: Right-handers wanting Microhinge roll and Double Wide stability
- Hand Orientation
- Right
- Shaft Length
- 34"
- Head Style
- Double Wide
- Neck Type
- Double Bend
- Face Technology
- Microhinge insert
- Grip Type
- Odyssey Pistol Grip
View on Amazon: Odyssey Microhinge Putter 34" Double Wide Affiliate link
This Odyssey putter features a Double Wide head style with a Microhinge insert face. The insert promotes immediate topspin for better forward roll. It includes Versa Alignment in a silver and black color scheme. You get a 34-inch shaft with a Double Bend neck and an Odyssey Pistol grip. It is designed for right-handed golfers seeking classic head shapes and reliable rolling performance.
Pros
- Microhinge insert delivers immediate topspin for forward roll
- Versa Alignment system aids aiming
- Double Wide head style offers stability
- Odyssey Pistol grip provides familiar feel
Cons
- Double Bend neck limits neck style options
- 34-inch length is fixed for this unit
- Right-hand orientation only
Good fit if
- You prefer a Double Wide head shape
- You want immediate topspin from the face
- You like the Odyssey Pistol grip
Skip if
- You need a left-handed option
- You prefer a Slant Neck or Crank Hosel
- You want a shaft length other than 34 inches
Verdict: Odyssey Microhinge Double Wide Putter suits right-handers who value the Microhinge insert for roll and the Double Wide head for stability. It is a solid choice for players who trust Versa Alignment and the classic Pistol grip.
Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #11 Putter, 34"
Best for: left-handed golfers with straight strokes
- Hand Orientation
- Left Hand
- Shaft Length
- 34"
- Neck Type
- Single Bend
- Face Technology
- Speed Optimized Face Technology
- Shaft Material
- UST Mamiya All-In
- Grip Type
- Oversized Grip
View on Amazon: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #11 Putter, 34" Affiliate link
This Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black putter features a single bend neck and an oversized grip for a stable stroke. The Speed Optimized Face Technology normalizes ball speed across the striking area. It uses a UST Mamiya All-In shaft for consistent feel. This left-handed model suits players seeking a straight or slight arc stroke with a black finish.
Pros
- Speed Optimized Face Technology for consistent distance
- UST Mamiya All-In shaft for stability
- Oversized grip for added control
- Designed for straight or slight arc strokes
Cons
- Left hand orientation limits right-handed buyers
- Single bend neck may not suit all stroke types
- Oversized grip may feel too large for some
Good fit if
- You use a straight or slight arc stroke
- You prefer a black finish
- You want an oversized grip
Skip if
- You are right-handed
- You prefer a center-shafted design
- You need a slant neck hosel
Verdict: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Putter is a solid option for left-handed golfers who want a stable, oversized grip and consistent ball speed. It fits players with straight or slight arc strokes who value a black aesthetic.
Cleveland Retreve HB Soft 2 Putter 34"
Best for: Straight or slight arc stroke players
- Hand Orientation
- Right Hand
- Shaft Length
- 34"
- Neck Type
- Single Bend
- Face Technology
- Speed Optimized Face Technology
- Shaft Material
- UST Mamiya All-In
- Grip Type
- Oversized Grip
View on Amazon: Cleveland Retreve HB Soft 2 Putter 34" Affiliate link
This Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black putter features a 34-inch shaft with a single bend neck and oversized grip. It uses UST Mamiya All-In shafts for stability and Speed Optimized Face Technology to normalize ball speed. The design targets straight or slight arc stroke types. It offers consistent swing feel through balanced weight distribution. This model suits players seeking predictable distance and a stable, high-tensile carbon fiber construction.
Pros
- UST Mamiya All-In shaft with high-tensile carbon fiber
- Speed Optimized Face Technology for consistent ball speed
- Oversized grip for enhanced stability
- Single bend neck for straight or slight arc strokes
- 20g butt-end weight for consistent swing feel
Cons
- Oversized grip may feel bulky for small hands
- Single bend neck limits toe hang options
- No adjustable weighting system visible in specs
Good fit if
- You prefer a single bend neck design
- You want an oversized grip for stability
- You have a straight or slight arc stroke
Skip if
- You need a double bend neck
- You prefer a standard-sized grip
- You require adjustable weighting
Verdict: Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black 34" Putter delivers stable, consistent performance for players with straight or slight arc strokes. Its oversized grip and single bend neck make it a solid choice for those prioritizing stability over adjustability.
TaylorMade Spider RED #3 34" Mallet
Best for: Right-handed golfers seeking stability
- Shaft Length
- 34"
- Head Style
- Mallet
- Face Technology
- Pure Roll Insert
- MOI Characteristics
- High MOI
- Hand Orientation
- Right
- Color
- Red
View on Amazon: TaylorMade Spider RED #3 34" Mallet Affiliate link
The TaylorMade Spider Red #3 is a mallet-style putter designed for stability and consistent roll. It features a high MOI construction with a lightweight 6061 aluminum core and a heavy 304 stainless steel frame. The Pure Roll insert promotes topspin for better distance control. Vibration damping PU foam enhances sound and feel. This 34-inch right-handed model offers a 5-inch width and 6-inch height for a balanced profile.
Pros
- High MOI from multi-material aluminum and steel construction
- Pure Roll insert increases topspin and forward roll
- PU foam damping improves sound and feel
- 34-inch length suits standard preferences
- Red color option for visibility
Cons
- Limited to right-hand orientation in this specific listing
- No adjustable weighting system mentioned in specs
- Standard 34-inch length may not fit all stroke types
Good fit if
- You want a high MOI mallet for stability
- You prefer the feel of a Pure Roll insert
- You like the red color aesthetic
Skip if
- You need a left-handed putter
- You prefer a blade-style head
- You require adjustable weight ports
Verdict: TaylorMade Spider Red #3 Putter is a stable mallet choice for golfers seeking consistent roll and a dampened feel. It suits right-handed players who prioritize forgiveness and a specific visual style.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 34" Putter | Odyssey Square 2 Square 34" Double Wide | TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter #3 34" | Odyssey Microhinge Putter 34" Double Wide | Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black #11 Putter, 34" | Cleveland Retreve HB Soft 2 Putter 34" | TaylorMade Spider RED #3 34" Mallet |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hand Orientation | Right Handed | Right Hand | Right Hand | Right | Left Hand | Right Hand | not stated |
| Shaft Length | 34" | 34" | 34 Inches | 34" | 34" | 34" | 34" |
| Head Style | not stated | not stated | Spider Tour #3 | Double Wide | not stated | not stated | Mallet |
| Neck Type | not stated | not stated | not stated | Double Bend | Single Bend | Single Bend | not stated |
| Face Technology | Pure Roll Insert | Ai-ONE Insert | not stated | Microhinge insert | Speed Optimized Face Technology | Speed Optimized Face Technology | Pure Roll Insert |
| Shaft Material | not stated | not stated | not stated | not stated | UST Mamiya All-In | UST Mamiya All-In | not stated |
| Grip Type | not stated | Oversized Grip | not stated | Odyssey Pistol Grip | Oversized Grip | Oversized Grip | not stated |
| Alignment System | not stated | not stated | patented alignment system | Versa Alignment | not stated | not stated | not stated |
| MOI Characteristics | not stated | not stated | high-MOI | not stated | not stated | not stated | High MOI |
| Color | Black | Black | Black | Black | Black | Black | Red |
| Length | 34 Inches | 34 Inches | 34 Inches | 34 Inches | 34 Inches | 34 Inches | 34 Inches |
| Dimensions | 8 × 4 × 35 inches | 43 × 5 × 6 inches | 38 × 6 × 6 inches | 43 × 5 × 6 inches | 43 × 5 × 6 inches | 43 × 5 × 6 inches | 42 × 5 × 6 inches |
| Weight | 6.07 ounces | not stated | 1.2 pounds | not stated | not stated | 1.2 pounds | 6.07 ounces |
| Size | 34" | 34" Length | 34" | 34" | 34" | 34" | 34" |
| Model | TP BLACK SOTO #1 '24 | AI-One Square 2 Square Double Wide | N7550326 | Microhinge Double Wide | HB Soft 2 Black #11 | HB Soft 2 Black Retreve | SPIDER RED #3 '24 |
Frequently asked questions
Which alternative offers the most forgiveness for off-center hits?
The TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter #3 is designed for high-MOI stability. Its mallet head measures 6 inches wide and weighs 1.2 pounds. This configuration helps maintain ball speed and direction on mishits. It is ideal for golfers who prioritize consistency and clear alignment over a blade-style feel.
Are there options available for left-handed players?
Yes, the Cleveland HB Soft 2 Black Putter #11 is available for left-handed golfers. It features a 34-inch shaft and an oversized grip for enhanced control. This model suits players with straight or slight arc strokes who want a stable, black-finished putter that delivers consistent ball speed.
How does the head width of the Odyssey Square 2 Square compare?
The Odyssey Square 2 Square Double Wide has a 5-inch head width. This is wider than the TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1, which measures 4 inches wide. The increased width provides greater face stability and a modern center-shafted look, appealing to players who value a square face at impact.
What insert technology do these alternatives use for roll?
The TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 uses a Pure Roll insert to promote consistent ball roll. The Odyssey Microhinge Double Wide features a Microhinge insert designed to grip the ball and reduce skid. Both technologies aim to improve forward roll and distance control compared to traditional face designs.
Which putter is best for players who want a mallet design?
The TaylorMade Spider Tour Black Putter #3 is a mallet-style option. It offers a 6-inch width and a 1.2-pound weight for maximum stability. The TaylorMade Spider RED #3 is another mallet choice, weighing 6.07 ounces. Both models provide high forgiveness and are suited for right-handed golfers seeking a stable head shape.
Do any alternatives feature Versa Alignment technology?
The Odyssey Microhinge Double Wide Putter includes Versa Alignment technology. This system uses high-contrast colors to help you square the face at address and impact. It is paired with a classic Pistol grip and a 34-inch shaft, making it a solid choice for right-handers who want visual guidance and stability.
Is there a lightweight alternative to the heavy mallet styles?
The TaylorMade TP Black Soto #1 weighs 6.07 ounces, which is lighter than the 1.2-pound Spider Tour. The Spider RED #3 also weighs 6.07 ounces. These lighter heads suit players who prefer a classic blade or smaller mallet feel over the substantial weight of traditional high-MOI mallet putters.